Life is nothing but a massive mix of joy, sorrow, and everything in between. As we navigate its twists and turns, we encounter well-worn phrases that attempt to provide solace or meaning. Growing up in a Southern Baptist/Evangelical Christian context, I, too, heard these sayings—often with a sense of urgency and certainty. But as life has unfolded, I find myself questioning their validity.
Life isn’t a Hallmark movie—it’s a gritty, unpredictable journey. Along the way, I’ve encountered phrases that promise solace or insight. Some resonate; others make me roll my eyes.
Thanks for reading Gina’s Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Subscribed
My major life experiences where these phrases came into play included…
Losing a Baby Late Term: In that silence, I grappled with the meaning of loss. Was there a reason? A purpose? Or was it simply the cruel randomness of existence?
Divorce and Incompatible Love: The unraveling of vows, the shards of a once-shared dream. In the wreckage, I questioned whether love could be both a blessing and a curse.
A Toxic Relationship and Unthinkable Propositions: His words dripped poison, corroding trust. And then, the unthinkable: my daughter, fragile and grieving, faced his indecent proposal. In that darkness, I wondered if “God’s” plan included such pain.
The Ultimate Loss: My Son’s Death at 25: Addiction stole him, piece by piece. The phone call—the final note in his struggle with mental health and drug addiction. The platitudes echoed hollow. Was this part of some cosmic design? Or was it chaos unbound?
Single Motherhood and the Comedy of Dating: Amid the storms, I juggled work, parenting, and the absurdity of dating apps. Swipe left, swipe right—sometimes life felt like a cosmic game show. Yet, in laughter, I found resilience.
So, like so many of you, I’m here as a witness to life’s paradoxes. These sayings perplex me. Some days, they anchor me; other days, they drift away. But in sharing them, perhaps we find solace together?
Let’s explore these phrases with empathy, honoring diverse beliefs and feelings.
1. “Everything Happens for a Reason”
- The Premise: This phrase suggests that every event—whether joyful or painful—has a divine purpose.
- Nuanced Viewpoints:
- The Optimistic Lens: Some argue that it’s not about causality but about finding meaning or growth in adversity. Perhaps challenges shape our character or lead us toward unexpected opportunities.
- The Skeptical Lens: Others reject this idea, emphasizing randomness, free will, and the complexity of life. Sometimes things just happen, devoid of cosmic intention.
- Voices to Consider:
- Viktor Frankl: A Holocaust survivor who explored the search for meaning in suffering through his book “Man’s Search for Meaning.”
- Rabbi Harold Kushner: Author of “When Bad Things Happen to Good People,” he grapples with theodicy—the question of why bad things happen to innocent people.
2. “God Won’t Give You More Than You Can Handle”
- The Premise: Often misattributed to 1 Corinthians 10:13, this saying implies that God tailors our burdens to our strength.
- Deeper Reflection:
- The Reality: Life does overwhelm us at times. We face loss, suffering, and challenges beyond our capacity.
- A Shift in Perspective: Instead of saying God won’t give us more, consider that God walks with us through our struggles, offering strength and comfort.
- Narrative to Explore: The biblical story of Job—a man who endured immense suffering and wrestled with God.
3. “We Can’t Understand It Now, But God Has a Plan”
- The Premise: This phrase seeks to provide solace in the face of mystery and suffering.
- Diverse Interpretations:
- Trust in Sovereignty: Some emphasize trust in God’s overarching plan, even when we lack understanding.
- Challenging the Notion: Others suggest that God’s plan may not always align with our expectations or neatly fit into our narratives.
- Thoughtful Voices:
- C.S. Lewis: In “The Problem of Pain,” Lewis grapples with the paradox of suffering and divine goodness.
- Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel: His exploration of divine mystery invites us to embrace awe and reverence.
Additional Sayings to Consider
- “When It Rains, It Pours”:
- Challenges often come in clusters. When one problem arises, it seems to attract more. Yet, perhaps resilience grows in the downpour.
- “This Too Shall Pass”:
- Both good and bad times are temporary. Knowing that adversity won’t last forever provides comfort and perspective.
- “Necessity Is the Mother of Invention”:
- Difficult circumstances inspire creativity and innovation. Adversity becomes the forge where resilience is shaped.
- “Smooth Seas Do Not Make Skillful Sailors”:
- Storms build expertise. Our challenges refine us, molding us into skillful navigators of life’s unpredictable waters.
- “When One Door Closes, Another Opens”:
- Even in setbacks, new opportunities await. Adaptability and open-mindedness reveal hidden pathways.
Embracing the Unanswered and the Shared Journey
As we grapple with these age-old sayings, we find ourselves at the crossroads of faith, doubt, and human vulnerability. Life’s complexities defy easy answers, and perhaps that’s where the true wisdom lies. Here are a few parting thoughts:
- The Mystery of Unanswered Questions:
- Some questions remain shrouded in mystery. Why do bad things happen? What purpose lies behind suffering? We may never fully grasp these answers, and that’s okay.
- Our shared humanity lies in our questioning—the wrestling with doubt, the seeking of meaning, and the yearning for connection.
- Compassion Across Beliefs:
- As we engage in these discussions, let’s honor diverse perspectives. Not everyone believes in God, and some find these sayings triggering. Compassion bridges the gaps between our beliefs.
- Perhaps the truest wisdom lies in acknowledging our shared vulnerability—the fragility of our existence and the courage to face it head-on.
- The Journey Continues:
- We’re all fellow travelers on this unpredictable road. Whether we walk in faith, skepticism, or uncertainty, we journey together.
- May we extend kindness to one another, recognizing that each person’s story is a unique thread woven into the grand tapestry of existence.
So, let’s keep questioning, seeking, and connecting. In the midst of life’s storms and sunsets, we find our shared humanity—the heartbeat that unites us all.
What are your thoughts on these “Everyday Expressions,” and how have they impacted you?